From: "Wahl, Eugene R" <wahle@alfred.edu>
To: "Jonathan Overpeck" <jto@u.arizona.edu>
Subject: RE: Wahl Ammann Climatic Change article on MBH/MM
Date: Tue, 28 Feb 2006 21:42:42 -0500
Cc: "Keith Briffa" <k.briffa@uea.ac.uk>, "Eystein Jansen" <eystein.jansen@geo.uib.no>, "Caspar Ammann" <ammann@ucar.edu>

Hello all:
 
Good news this day.  The Wahl-Ammann paper also has been given fully accepted status today by Stephen Schneider.  I copy his affirmation of this below, and after that his remark from earlier this month regarding this status being equivalent to "in press".  I hope this meets the deadline of before March 1 for citation.
 
Peace, Gene
 
 
*********************************  first copied message **************************************
 
RE: provision of Wahl and Ammann ms 3321 to NAS committee
Stephen H Schneider [shs@stanford.edu]
	 You replied on 2/28/2006 9:33 PM.	
 	 Follow up	
To: 	 Wahl, Eugene R
Cc: 	 katarina kivel
 
Hello from Sydney. I have now read your responses the the rereviewer and
am satisfied you have done more than an adequate job. The paper is now
accepted and you can post it where you wish with that designation. Let me
know if there is anything else to do. Congratulations, Steve


 
*********************************  second copied message **************************************
 
RE: Wahl and Ammann ms 3321
Stephen H Schneider [shs@stanford.edu]
	 You replied on 2/28/2006 7:06 PM.	
 	 Follow up	
To: 	 Wahl, Eugene R
Cc: 	 katarina kivel
 
your interpretation is fine--get me the revision soon so I have time to
assess your responses in light of reviews in time!  Look forward to
recievieng it, Steve

On Sat, 11 Feb 2006, Wahl, Eugene R wrote:

> Hello Steve:
>
> Caspar and I expect to have the final manuscript to you in 7-10 days with all the revisions you requested in December.  I have recently had some correspondance with Jonathan Overpeck about this, in his IPCC role.  He says that the paper needs to be in press by the end of February to be acceptable to be cited in the SOD.  [I had thought that we had passed all chance for citation in the next IPCC report back in December, but Peck has made it known to me this is not so.]
>
> He and I have communicated re: what "in press" means for Climatic Change, and I agreed to contact you to have a clear definition.  What I have understood from our conversations before is that if you receive the mss and move it from "provisionally accepted" status to "accepted", then this can be considered in press, in light of CC being a journal of record.
>
> Peace, Gene
> Dr. Eugene R. Wahl
> Asst. Professor of Environmental Studies
> Alfred University
>

*************************** end of copied messages *********************
 
Dr. Eugene R. Wahl
Asst. Professor of Environmental Studies
Alfred University
 
607-871-2604
1 Saxon Drive
Alfred, NY 14802 

 

